Website Redesign SEO: How Plano Small Businesses Can Keep Their Google Rankings
A new website should bring in more customers, not fewer. Here is how to redesign your site without losing the Google rankings you have already earned.
A new website is exciting, until the phone stops ringing. One of the most common problems small businesses run into is a redesign that looks great but quietly wipes out years of Google rankings. The good news is that website redesign SEO mostly comes down to a short checklist done before, during and after launch. This guide from Web Designer Plano walks Plano and DFW business owners through what to protect, what to change, and how to tell if something went wrong.
Why a Website Redesign Can Hurt Your SEO
Google doesn't rank "your website" as a single thing. It ranks individual pages at specific web addresses (URLs). When a redesign changes those addresses, removes pages, or rewrites content, Google has to figure out what happened to everything it already knew about your site.
The most common ways redesigns lose traffic:
- Changed URLs with no redirects. Old links from Google, other websites and your own social profiles suddenly lead to "page not found" errors.
- Deleted pages that were bringing in visitors. A page that looked unimportant may have been your top source of calls.
- Lost text. Swapping helpful written content for big images or short slogans leaves Google less to understand.
- Missing titles and descriptions. Page titles and meta descriptions often get left blank or reset to defaults.
- A test site left blocked from search. Settings meant to hide the unfinished site sometimes go live with it.
Some movement is normal even when everything is done right. Google's site move guide says to "expect temporary fluctuation in site ranking during the move," and notes that "a small to medium-sized website can take a few weeks for most pages to move."
Before Launch: Your Website Redesign SEO Checklist
Most of the protection happens before the new site goes live. Work through these steps with your designer:
- List every page on your current site. Use your XML sitemap, your website platform's page list, or Google Search Console. Our Google Search Console setup guide shows how to get access if you don't have it yet.
- Find your most valuable pages. In Search Console, look at the Performance report and note which pages get the most clicks. These are the ones you can't afford to lose.
- Save your current titles, descriptions and headings. A simple spreadsheet is fine. You'll compare against it later.
- Keep the same URLs when you can. If
/roof-repair/already ranks, don't rename it to/services/roofing-repairs/just because the new design looks different. Our post on URL structure explains what makes a good address. - Keep (or improve) the words that work. A fresh look doesn't require throwing away content that already answers customer questions.
Redirects: The Most Important Part of Website Redesign SEO
If any URL does change, it needs a redirect. A redirect automatically sends visitors and search engines from the old address to the new one.
Google is specific about which kind to use. Its redirects documentation explains that 301 and 308 redirects "mean that a page has permanently moved to a new location," while temporary ones (302 and 307) tell Google to keep showing the old page in results. For a redesign, you almost always want permanent 301 redirects.
A few rules from Google's site move guide worth knowing:
- Map every old URL to its closest new match. Send the old "Water Heater Repair" page to the new water heater page, not to the homepage.
- Permanent redirects don't cost you ranking power. Google says "301 and other permanent redirects don't cause a loss in PageRank."
- Leave redirects in place. Google recommends keeping them "for as long as possible, generally at least 1 year."
Launch Day: Quick Checks That Catch Big Problems
On the day the new site goes live, take 30 minutes to check:
- Search visibility is on. Make sure your platform's "discourage search engines" or "hide from search" setting is turned off.
- Old URLs redirect. Type several old addresses into your browser and confirm each lands on the right new page.
- Internal links point to new URLs. Menus, buttons and in-text links should go straight to the new addresses, not through redirects.
- Your phone number and contact form work on both desktop and mobile.
- Your new sitemap is submitted in Google Search Console.
- Business listings are updated. Update links on your Google Business Profile, Facebook and other profiles if any URLs changed.
After Launch: How to Monitor Your Rankings
For the first few weeks, check Google Search Console about once a week. Watch the Pages report for new "Not found (404)" errors, and compare clicks for your top pages against the numbers you saved before launch. If you find broken pages, our guide to fixing broken links and 404 errors covers what to do.
A small, temporary dip that recovers is normal. A steep drop that keeps going usually points to a specific problem, like missing redirects or blocked pages, and it's worth fixing quickly.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will redesigning my website hurt my Google rankings?
It doesn't have to. Rankings may move around for a few weeks while Google recrawls your site, but keeping URLs, content and redirects in order helps protect what you've built.
Do I need redirects if my URLs stay the same?
No. If every page keeps the same address, there's nothing to redirect. You still need to check titles, content and search settings after launch.
How long should I keep 301 redirects?
Google recommends keeping them generally at least one year, and for users, consider keeping them indefinitely so old links keep working.
Should I change my domain name during a redesign?
Only if you have a strong business reason. A domain change is a bigger move that affects every URL, so it's simpler to keep your current domain when you can.
Planning a new website and want to keep the rankings you already have? Web Designer Plano builds fast, SEO-ready websites for small businesses across Plano, Frisco, Allen, McKinney and the rest of DFW. We handle the technical side so you can focus on running your business.
- See our web design services
- Get a free quote
- Call or text: (972) 439-5263
- Email: [email protected]
Ready to put this into practice?
Get a free quote from a real Plano web designer.
Get a Free Quote →